Regarding the Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal, Oakland City Attorney Barbara Parker’s recent newsletter made several misleading claims and misstatements of facts including this: “In 2015, the City learned that Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal (OBOT) was seeking to develop a coal terminal on the site.”
That statement was apparently designed by the Oakland City Attorney to have Oaklanders avoid reading information that would disprove it – what follows is that information.
History Of The City Of Oakland’s Partnership With California Capital Investment Group In A Multi-Commodity Bulk Terminal
• On July 21, 2009, the City of Oakland selected California Capital Investment Group (CCIG) Oakland Global as the developer for the reuse plan of the former Oakland Army Base, including the West Gateway portion. Fro the start, the land use plan for the West Gateway included a proposal for the development and operation of a multi-commodity bulk terminal, capitalizing on the site’s unique access to existing rail operations in immediate proximity to a deep-water port.
• As originally planned in and around 2010, the original prospective tenant at OBOT was Kinder Morgan. This fact was communicated to the City, and in October 2011, a Kinder Morgan presentation, present in the City of Oakland’s records from that time, shows that the typical throughput for a Kinder Morgan facility at that time included 34 percent coal and 14 percent Petcoke among other prospective commodities.
• In 2009, the City of Oakland ordered a market study to assess the viability of the Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal. That study, which was released April of 2012, specifically referred to the market for coal, and identified Utah as a likely provider for that commodity and for the OBOT’s successful operation.
Later that same year, then Oakland Assistant City Administrator Fred Blackwell gave an interview to this video-blogger and mentioned on video that iron ore would be one of the commodities handled in the facility. It’s commonly known that steel is produced with both coal and iron ore; no steel production facility would order iron ore and not coal. Also, Blackwell’s statements are public evidence the City of Oakland knew OBOT would be a bulk, multi-commodity terminal well before 2015.
• In January 2013, The City of Oakland’s own Long Range Management Plan, prepared by City staff and consultants, and as required by governing agreements with the State of California and other entities that were and are supporting and funding the project, expressly described the proposed bulk terminal as handling “lumber, coal, and sulfur…”
That document was approved by City of Oakland governing bodies and forwarded to the necessary State of California and other agencies.
• In January 2013, staff of the Port of Oakland, a subsidiary of the City of Oakland, emailed regarding the prospect of coal being transported through the Port rail yard.
• In May 2013, the Port of Oakland commissioned a study by Lautsch Davis:
That Lautsch Davis study identified coal as one of several potential commodities for the new State Transportation Corridor Improvement Fund-subsidized rail yard to be at the former Oakland Army Base.
• City of Oakland project managers Pat Cashman and Doug Cole, in their analysis, employed the Metro Ports Wharf G in Long Beach, the Port of Stockton, and the Richmond-Levine Terminal as comparable facilities upon which the proposed bulk terminal and its operations would be patterned and against which what’s now called OBOT would compete. All of those comparable facilities handle coal, and that was confirmed by, among other things, a video presentation they admitted they saw in March of 2013.
• The City of Oakland entitled and vested OBOT’s multi-commodity bulk terminal to be built and operated on July 16, 2013.
• Kinder Morgan withdrew from the Exclusive Negotiating Agreement with OBOT in April 2014.
• The City of Oakland approved a renegotiated project obligations and financing agreements where the developer assumed much greater obligations in exchange for expedited timing for processing and approval of OBOT. It was called the “Mid Project Budget Revise” and done on November 4th, 2014.
The Mid Project Budget Revise also identified the sublease between OBOT and Terminal Logistics Solutions (TLS), following Kinder Morgan’s withdraw from consideration.
• OBOT entered into an option agreement with TLS on November 4, 2014. TLS’s commodity line-up was similar to Kinder Morgan’s and as shown in their presentation to City staff and officials in October of 2014.
• Even had the City of Oakland not been directly provided all of the information noted above, a simple Google or Yahoo online search, then and now, shows the standard and prevalent commodities that make up the market of “bulk commodities cargo” shipped daily by such facilities: “Bulk cargo is commodity cargo that is transported unpackaged in large quantities. It refers to material in either liquid or granular, particulate form, as a mass of relatively small solids, such as petroleum/crude oil, grain, coal, or gravel.”
• The City of Oakland, both staff and elected officials, knew that the Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal was to be a bulk, multi-commodity terminal well before 2015, and there’s ample evidence that shows that truth.
The Oakland City Attorney built a false narrative just to renege on its obligations, and its efforts were exposed in Federal court. A Federal District Court judge revealed every aspect of the City of Oakland’s fake news effort to kill the Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal, so long as it would not unilaterally commit to not handle coal and in direct avoidance of market norms and expectations, considering worldwide commodity use.
The Port of Oakland has long considered a bulk terminal, and as far back as 1990 – it was always assumed it would handle many commodities for shipment, including coal.
You may also like
Oakland News Now Recent Posts
- Raiders Rumors Mailbag: Amik Robertson Could Be Traded? Trade For Eagles OT Andre Dillard? October 28, 2021
- FULL MATCH – John Cena vs. Bobby Lashley – WWE Title Match: WWE Great American Bash 2007 October 28, 2021
- Chicago Bears Trade Rumors: 5 NFL Trade Ideas Feat. Allen Robinson, Robert Quinn & Andre Dillard October 28, 2021
- San Francisco, California – 2019 October 28, 2021
- Big call buying in S&P Biotech (XBI) October 28, 2021
- Free NBA Picks Today | SPURS vs MAVERICKS Predictions (10/28/21) NBA Best Bets and NBA Player Props October 28, 2021
- Las Vegas Raiders SHOULD Trade for These Players! October 28, 2021
- Guy Fieri Tries Kare Kare | Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives | Food Network October 28, 2021
- Omar Gooding on Allegations Against Cuba Gooding Jr. By 22 Women (Part 16) October 28, 2021
- How Michael Mayer fit perfectly with Notre Dame from the start | ND on NBC Podcast | NBC Sports October 28, 2021
- Chicago Bears host the San Francisco 49ers Game Preview (Week 8) October 28, 2021
- Biden Lays Out Framework For Spending Plan, But Still Needs Democratic Support October 28, 2021
- UFC 267: Pre-fight Press Conference Highlights October 28, 2021
- Chris Simms’ prop bets for Packers vs. Cardinals | Chris Simms Unbuttoned | NBC Sports October 28, 2021
- Depleted Packers face tall task vs. unbeaten Cardinals | Chris Simms Unbuttoned | NBC Sports October 28, 2021
- Key Democrats have yet to commit to Biden’s economic plan framework October 28, 2021
- Pres. Biden’s spending framework ‘will likely pass’ by year-end October 28, 2021
- Crypto investing tips: Investors need to recognize risks associated with the asset class: ShoreHaven October 28, 2021
- Sacramento County health officials are giving a COVID briefing October 28, 2021
- Free NBA Picks Today | KNICKS vs BULLS Predictions (10/28/21) NBA Best Bets and NBA Player Props October 28, 2021
- 2023 Chevrolet Corvette Z06 October 28, 2021
- Starbucks raises wages, Activision Blizzard CEO details pay cut, Third Point buys stake in Shell October 28, 2021
- Todd Bowles | Press Conference October 28, 2021
- NFL Week 8 DraftKings & FanDuel DFS Picks And Betting Angles Breakdown – The Gameplan October 28, 2021
- NFL | Thursday Night Football | Packers vs Cardinals | Picks and Betting Predictions October 28, 2021
- AG Garland defends memo on violent threats to school boards October 28, 2021
- Louis Riddick on the hottest topics in the NFL | SportsNation October 28, 2021
- Australia Rejects U.S., EU Call for Global Methane Agreement October 28, 2021
- Boosie on Calling IG’s President Adam Mosseri a B**** After Losing 12M Follower Page (Part 31) October 28, 2021
- ‘Squid Game’ Creator Responds to LeBron James’ Criticism of The Show’s Ending | THR News October 28, 2021
- Watch live: Biden hails US climate spending ‘significant investment’ October 28, 2021
- Stanley Black & Decker CEO on earnings beat and cutting outlook October 28, 2021
- Saad Aljabri: a story worthy of Hollywood October 28, 2021
- 2020 Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD Sulphur Springs, TX #P2130 October 28, 2021
- Bash: Biden is telling Democrats the train is leaving the station October 28, 2021
- Vintage KSDK: Gateway Arch is completed in 1965 October 28, 2021
- NFL Trade Rumors: 7 BLOCKBUSTER Trades That Should Happen Before The 2021 NFL Trade Deadline October 28, 2021
- Josh Brown on his ‘Moms are Cool’ financial advice program October 28, 2021
- How will injuries affect Week 8 in the NFL? | SportsNation October 28, 2021
- Tom Brady | Press Conference October 28, 2021