It’s Gavin Newsom versus the out-of-nowhere political star that is John Cox, or “John H. Cox American Accountant” as he’s referred to on Google Trends. And that leads to the raison d’etre for this post: to determine if Google Trends got it wrong, or if this blogger, me, got Google Trends wrong, or something in between.
I want to thank a viewer for pointing out, in the comments to another related video, that if I tried just “John Cox” as a search term, rather that the “John H. Cox American Accountant” choice that I selected on Google News, then a different result would appear. But before I continue, let me catch you up on what I am writing about.
In brief, I was intrigued with the idea that Google Trends (which attempts to show what search terms a population is looking for using the Google Search Engine at any given time) could be a predictor of elections other than that for POTUS. When I ran my initial tests of this theory, I ran Google Trends using the top candidates (not all of the 33, as Google Trends can only fit five at a time, and the others listed failed to move the search needle to even be worth noting) and with “John H. Cox American Accountant”, the Google Trends feedback had “John H. Cox American Accountant” with low search intensity.
But then the viewer, who goes by a YouTube name that’s not his or her real name, and is xxTheGhilliedGhostxx chimed in with “I noticed your results show “John H. Cox.” If you put simply “John Cox” into Google trends, his numbers are much higher. I just compared the top 4 candidates on Google Trends, and as of right now, the results are: Gavin Newsom:100 John Cox: 35 Travis Allen: 31 Antonio Villaraigosa: 26 I predict it will be Newsom vs Cox in November.”
So I tried his suggestion, but used john cox, and for a California-focused Google Trends search test, and received the same low result as for “John H. Cox American Accountant”. Then, it occurred to me to replicate what the viewer did exactly as it was done. I didn’t have a screen shot of the YouTube’s result, so I had to guess that I should capitalize the J and the C in John Cox. That made the difference, and the result is below.
With that chart, we see a result more in line with what the UC Berkeley Institurte of Governmental Studies department learned after their poll published May 31st: that Cox was competitive with Former LA Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, Travis Allen, and over John Chiang. But that said, Cox never had a giant bump that was in Newsom territory. Moreover, the chart, for some reason, only goes to Monday, June 4th, but even then, it’s a pure assumption to think Cox’s 34 intensity (which still put him below Allen and Villaraigosa but by five points and two points respectively) would have jumped to say “50”. It brings the question, how could Cox emerge to almost beat Newsom in the real election, but not have that reflected in Google Trends.
One possible answer has to do with the low voter turnout. Google Trends captures what people search for, but for politics in local elections is not the perfect predictor of what will happen in an off-year local contest. That said, the overall fact is, Google Trends got it mosly right – but not turnout. And while the Berkeley-IGS poll didn’t predict voter turnout directly, it did indirectly via the result. Berkeley-IGS calling mostly traditional landlines rather than cell phones told us that older voters mostly likely to get to the polls, were going to make Cox the second place choice – and that’s what happened. But even then, it did not capture the pure enthusiam for Cox.
So, while Google Trends didn’t get it exacly right, it did reflect the degree of interest in the candidates and it predicted Newsom’s win. Google Trends can’t replace a good Berkeley-IGS poll, but should be used in conjunction with it: Google Trends shows degree of interest in a candidate, the Berkeley-IGS poll methodology shows the degree that turnout, low or high, will effect an election.
Oakland News Now Recent Posts
- Las Vegas Raiders Defense Is The Key To Victory In Week By Eric Pangilinan September 23, 2021
- RecallOakland.com Website For Stupid Idea Of Recalling Mayor Schaaf Months Before She’s Termed Out September 23, 2021
- Nintendo Reveals Cast For The Mario Movie in 2022. Yes This Is Real, By: Vinny Lospinuso September 23, 2021
- BREAKING: Arrest Warrant Issued for Brian Laundrie in Gabby Petito’s Death September 23, 2021
- Las Vegas Raiders Tom Flores To Receive Hall Of Fame Ring At Allegiant Stadium By Eric Pangilinan September 23, 2021
- Justin Fields First NFL Start Will Come Against The Browns | Pat McAfee Reacts September 23, 2021
- Coach Bradley, Coach Olson, Denzel Perryman and Kenyan Drake Presser – 9.23.21 | Las Vegas Raiders September 23, 2021
- Supermodel Linda Evangelista Has Been “Brutally Disfigured” by Procedure Done 5 Years Ago | PEOPLE September 23, 2021
- Author Jameis1of1 Talks About Jameis Winston And Gives Thoughts On Pats vs Saints Game September 23, 2021
- Kate Scott Is Philadelphia’s First Female Sports Broadcaster – That’s No Accident – Here’s Why September 23, 2021
- Mom Gets Surprise Giant Gift Box From Rocket Mortgage Sent Via UPS September 23, 2021
- How U.C. Berkeley Beat Harvard And Yale To Become The Best College In America | Forbes September 23, 2021
- Judge Orders UC Berkeley To Freeze Enrollment After Neighborhood Group Sues September 23, 2021
- Save 1921 Walnut St. Berkeley – Tenants Protest Demolition, UC Berkeley, Mayor Jesse Arreguin Actions September 23, 2021
- 30 Weirdest Things Ever Caught On Security Cameras & CCTV ! September 23, 2021
- The Raiders Are LETHAL With Derek Carr and Jon Gruden in Sync | Tiki and Tierney September 23, 2021
- Melvin Van Peebles on Bill Cosby Allegations; Being a Pioneer September 23, 2021
- Unstoppable: Melvin Van Peebles, Gordon Parks, and Ossie Davis in Conversation (2005) September 23, 2021
- Groundbreaking Filmmaker Melvin Van Peebles Has Died September 23, 2021
- R.I.P Mario Van Peebles Dad, Speaks On How His Father Melvin Van Peebles Died September 23, 2021
- 2021 09 21 Meeting with DSP UC Berkeley Students with Disabilities Coalition PART 2 September 23, 2021
- Nobel Prize Medal Presented to UC Berkeley Chemistry Professor Jennifer Doudna at her Berkeley Home September 23, 2021
- Oakland school district votes on vaccine mandate September 23, 2021
- Lakefront Home For Sale – 195 Honey Ln Fayetteville GA 30214 September 23, 2021
- Home For Sale – Introducing, 260 Camelot Fayetteville, Georgia September 23, 2021
- Home For Sale 3800 California Street Oakland, CA | ColdwellBankerHomes.com September 23, 2021
- Oakland Officer, Suspect Wounded In Shootout; Suspect Surrenders After Tense Standoff September 23, 2021
- Weather Forecast Oakland, California ▶ Oakland weather Forecast 09/23/2021 September 23, 2021
- COVID Vaccinations: Oakland Unified School District Board Approves COVID Vaccination Mandate For Students September 23, 2021
- Oakland Unified School District Board Discusses Vaccine Mandate for Students, Staff September 23, 2021
- Woman Wanted For Pulling Gun On Chipotle Worker In Philadelphia September 23, 2021
- Go Fund Me For Raider Nation’s Black Hole Rob Rivera’s Funeral By Rachel Rivera September 23, 2021
- Gabby Petito case: Crews use new tools in the search for Brian Laundrie September 23, 2021
- Hey EBX & Hella Coastal – Brothers Brewing Co Was Oakland’s First Black Brewery, And Then There Was Pican Restaurant September 23, 2021
- Las Vegas Raiders NFL Pro football Focus Ranked Maxx Crosby Number 1 Edge Rusher By Eric Pangilinan September 22, 2021
- Raiders Steve Wisniewski Nominated For 2022 Pro Football Hall of Fame Class, By: Vinny Lospinuso September 22, 2021
- Brian Laundrie search: What led police to the Carlton Reserve? September 22, 2021
- Laundrie neighbor says she saw Brian after his return September 22, 2021
- Former Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Michael Baden On Gabby Petito’s Autopsy Findings September 22, 2021
- Oakland Athletics Unveil 2022 Season Ticket Plans and Pricing by Richard Haick September 22, 2021