Saturday 8th of August 2020 03:57:11 AM GMT

Ballinger vs. City of Oakland Lawsuit Wrongly Challenges Tenant Protection Ordinance

(Last Updated On: December 29, 2018)

The City of ’s newish law protecting tenants in the event of landlord takeover of their place to live is being challenged in the case of Ballinger vs. City of . The suit is being filed by the conservative Pacific Legal Foundation on behalf of Lyndsey and Sharon Ballinger.

According to the website of the Pacific Legal Foundation:

When the Air Force reassigned Lyndsey and Sharon Ballinger to Washington DC, in 2015, they kept their house in , California, renting it on a month-to-month lease so they could return to it. When the couple and their two small children came home this spring, a new city law forced them to pay their tech-sector tenants $6,500—for the right to move back into their own home. The law aims to help residents affected by soaring housing costs. But because the law’s good intent comes at the expense of their constitutional protections, the Ballingers filed a federal lawsuit.

The Pacific Legal Foundation completely misunderstands Constitutional Law as it applies to property. The concern of the application of the U.S. Constitution with respect to property has been in the area of eminent domain, not a tenant’s right to appropriate resolution of a living situation. The conservative advocacy group is obviously confused between what is the law and what it allows, and what they think the law should allow. That much is clear on the webpage of the case the Institute has established.

First, it reads “The Constitution grants all Americans the right to make reasonable use of their property. Local governments can’t trample these protections to solve a housing crisis created by government policies.” That’s a statement of one part fact, the “ reasonable use of their property” and one part opinion, “ Local governments can’t trample these protections to solve a housing crisis created by government policies”.

Second, it reads “People who want to move back into their own homes should be able to do so without paying for their tenants to go elsewhere” and “Bureaucratic overreach disguised as good intent cannot come at the expense of our constitutional protections”. That’s opinion, and in no way expresses any understanding of tenant’s rights law.

Also, the Pacific Legal Foundation arguably deliberately mischaracterized the City of compensation law as paying the tenants for the right to move back into their own place. No, that’s not the way the City’s law works: the legal intent of the ordinance is to pay the tenant to make it easier for that person to move from the landlord’s property without being made homeless in the process.

Thus, the entire intellectual argument of the Pacific Legal Institute is laughable at best. The organization would do well to read the Supreme Court of California 1985 case of Kendall v. Ernest Pestana. The upshot of the resolution of that case was this: asking a tenant to move out without compensation, move the tenant’s furniture or otherwise accommodate the landlord’s plans is a breach of what is called “the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.” The key word that applies to Ballinger vs. City of is “ asking a tenant to move out without compensation.”

Also look at the success of Portland’s version of the Oakland law. It is now permanent, and has withstood considerable legal review.

“The Portland City Council this morning unanimously expanded and made permanent the requirement that landlords pay between $2,900 and $4,500 in tenant moving expenses in some instances.”

And the City of San Leandro, next door to , has its own Tenant Relocation Assistance Ordinance. The city law is spreading like wildfire and for a good reason: as a response to the many examples immoral actions of some landlords that have contributed to this homeless crisis.

This lawsuit also shows the folly of basing a legal attack on a conservative political agenda, and not moral fairness. The Pacific Legal Foundation does not at all refer to any moral rights of the tenant, and presents an argument that seems to belittle the right of the tenant.

This lawsuit should be a clear winner for the City of . The Pacific Legal Foundation should stop trying to bend the law to fit conservative ideas and focus more on the classic moral rights of life, liberty, and happiness that the Constitution defends in America, regardless of political positions or party concerns.

The City of ’s moto is “Love Life” – that’s for a good set of reasons, as the Pacific Legal Foundation will learn.


In the comment section below, someone who goes by the common name of Jasmine Zamora on Disqus, and who apparently represents a public relations effort as the person has a track-record of only commenting her opposition only to the Prop 10 rent control law that failed in the November election and on this issue, none-the-less raised a good question:

In the case at hand, the City of took over $6000 from a veteran couple and put that $6000 in the hands of two software engineers. How much do veterans earn? How much do software engineers earn? Do you think this arrangement under the ordinance is just?

At-Large Councilmember Rebecca Kaplan has said that the law does have a provision for an owner that’s a “hardship” case, but it was designed with the assumption that the owner has the money to pay the amortized tenant relocation assistance payments.

Also, I checked the “Frequently Asked Questions” part of the Rental Relocation Assistance Ordinance, on the matter, and learned something else.

The City Attorney’s FAQ reads that, if the owners did live in the place of residence and are seeking to move back in, and informed the tenant that they planned to do so and the rights of the owners are in the agreement, then no relocation payment is to be made.

That begs a new question: is the couple indeed able to answer the question did they “live in the place of residence and are seeking to move back in, and informed the tenant that they planned to do so and the rights of the owners are in the agreement”? If the answer is yes, then they don’t have to pay the relocation agreement.

If the judge finds that they don’t have to pay the agreement, then there’s no need for a lawsuit to strike down an ordinance because of “payment barrier” issues.

Stay tuned., Now, @Now is by Media, Inc. with CEO Zenophon Abraham AKA Now Commentary Partner, California blogger / ger @ZennieAbraham . Hire @Media, Inc to tell your story.

Media uses smartphones enabling our 98-blog network, specially-made blogs, website, social media platforms covering politics, , sports, and tech, @city, City Council, North , East , Montclair, Adams Point, Uptown food culture, City, Cemetery, crime, directions, airport, , California ghetto, , California Map, Raiders, City Hall Plaza, East , Jack London Square, London Square, Golden State Warriors, Chase Center, Bob Myers, Joe Lacob, Peter Guber, NBC Bay Area, Council-Member, Councilmember, Council President, Mayor of , Public-Safety, Affordable Housing, BBQ Becky Dr. Jennifer Schulte , Jogger Joe Henry Sintay, crime , Chauncey Bailey, Bank of America loans, COVID-19 updates, homeless , SF Bay Area , artists, @breakingbayarea, Emeryville, Atlanta , Chevron Ecuador, Steven Donziger, Fayetteville GA , @FayettevilleGA Fayette County Georgia, San Francisco , San Jose . Also, David Rubin Academy Awards, The Oscars ceremony ,Tom Hanks, Skyline High School, Sports, Panthers, Coliseum, Honda of , Arena, Raiders, Las Vegas Raiders, Las Vegas Stadium Construction, Allegiant Stadium, Las Vegas Stadium Authority, NBA, NFL, NFL Draft, NFL Combine, CES Las Vegas tech, San Diego Comic Con sci-fi. @GrandLakeTheater @LasVegasHotels, Penny Dreadful City of Angels, Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, AMPAS

Media has content development and online reputation management clients like Insight Terminal Solutions @InsightTerminalSolutions and The Bulk and Oversized Terminal, with California Capital Investment Group Managing Partner Phillip Phil Tagami @PhilTagami co-developer, @JohnSiegel John Siegel as ITS CEO exposing coal and fake . has helped Maria Ayerdi Kaplan @MariaAyerdiKaplan, developer of Salesforce Transit Center in San Francisco, Kofi Bonner Five Points, San Francisco Shipyard, and Flowsent capture the Cannabis Delivery Dispensary @Cannabis market with fitness model female bodybuilder Laura Ehlen and weedmaps help. We’ve partnered with CoLoursTV, CNN, , Google, NBC, Vice, Post / Post Group, Landis PR, and other media organizations. Competition: The SF Chronicle, San Francisco Chronicle, Streetsblog San Francisco,, San Francisco Business Times,, NY Times, Salt Lake Tribune, LA Times, Daily Californian, KQED, KALX, KPIX, KRON, Las Vegas Review Journal, East Bay Express, Tribune, Voices, The Mercury , AJC, Atlanta Journal Constitution, Hoodline

WebiMax, Gadook, VJG Interactive, LocalEdge, Digital Firefly Marketing, GreyBox Creative, Igniyte, Reputation Rhino, Netmark, Outspoken Media, SEOValley, WebpageFX, NetReputati, san francisco reputation management, atlanta reputation management, los angeles reputation management, Indeed, airbnb, pinterest, credit karma, southwest airlines, mcdonalds, united airlines, Peel-A-Pound Soup, drudge report, astros, 49ers, frontier airlines, tractor supply, warriors, alaska airlines, buffalo wild wings, horoscope, shein, raiders, uhaul, ted bundy, nba finals, michaels coupon, Tua Tagovailoa, cheesecake factory, golden state warriors, kevin durant, realtor com, stephen curry, walgreens photo, drudge, facebook sign in, funny memes, hbo go, hbo now, raiders, national night out, vistaprint, braves, san francisco 49ers, monday night football, newegg, travis scott, zion williamson, kohls coupons, lands end, nancy pelosi, kohls coupon, hotwire, kamala harris, Patrick Mahomes, harry potter, giants, craigslist sf, craig newmark, vic beasley, california earthquake, boston weather, las vegas weather, Eric Metz, sf giants, san francisco weather, san francisco, los angeles weather, lord and taylor, star wars, star wars episode, star trek, star trek discovery, william shatner,,, leonard nimoy, j.j.abrams, jimmy garoppolo, hawaiian airlines, detective pikachu, clint eastwood, bed bath and beyond coupon, abercrombie, pewdiepie, sfgate, sc lottery, san diego weather, san antonio weather, southwest flights, pikachu, golden state, myatt, just mercy, french open, colourpop, cam newton, anna kendrick, actor, sexual harrassment, klay thompson, harbor freight coupon, robin williams, protest in , portland protest, Berkeley protest, Chicago protest, LA protest, Howard Terminal Ballpark, Seattle protest, portland weather, phoenix weather, north carolina, macbook, how, bath and body works coupon, The Pandemic, sports events,googleflights, daytona 500, daily horoscope, ashton kutcher, mask, Economic Stimulus, andrew luck, alamo drafthouse, 49ers schedule, trump tweets, thanksgiving,How to, What is, How do I, What do I, Who is? , Electronic Frontier Foundation, Howard Terminal Ballpark, Natalie Silver, Pass It On, Barbara Leslie, Yui Hay Lee, Andreas Cluver, White Journalists, Blacks In Media, David Rubin, Frances Dinkelspiel, Alana Nguyen SFGate, Cat Brooks, Anti Police-Terror Project, Mountain Mike’s Pizza, Glenview, Restorative Justice, School Crossing Guards

Bill Belichick ,New England Patriots, Sean Payton, New Orleans Saints, Andy Reid, Kansas City Chiefs , John Harbaugh, Baltimore Ravens, Sean McVay, Los Angeles Rams, Mike Tomlin, Pittsburgh Steelers, Kyle Shanahan, San Francisco 49ers, Pete Carroll, Seattle Seahawks, Bruce Arians, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Frank Reich, Indianapolis Colts , Mike Zimmer , Minnesota Vikings , Doug Pederson, Philadelphia Eagles , Mike Vrabel, Tennessee Titans , Sean McDermott, Buffalo Bills , Matt Nagy, Chicago Bears , Kliff Kingsbury, Arizona Cardinals , Zac Taylor, Cincinnati Bengals, Bill O’Brien, Houston Texans, Kevin Stefanski, Cleveland Browns, Ron Rivera, Washington Redskins , Brian Flores, Miami Dolphins , Joe Judge, New York Giants, Mike McCarthy, Dallas Cowboys, Matt Rhule, Carolina Panthers, Jon Gruden, Las Vegas Raiders, Matt LaFleur, Green Bay Packers, Anthony Lynn, Los Angeles Chargers, Vic Fangio, Denver Broncos, Dan Quinn, Atlanta Falcons, Matt Patricia, Detroit Lions, Doug Marrone, Jacksonville Jaguars, Adam Gase, New York Jets

Also Elon Musk, r , Nura Gabbara, Pat Abraham Yerger, Patricia Yerger, @LibbySchaaf, Councilmember Nikki Fortunato Bas, Dan Kalb of District 1, Loren Taylor, Lynette Gibson McElhaney, Sheng Thao, Noel Gallo, Robert Bobb, Rebecca Kaplan, Larry Reid, Tech Entrepreneur Sarah Lacy, Personal Trainer Megan Avalon Buffed Barbie, Social Media Pioneer Marc Canter, Beth Schnitzer, Spritz Marketing, Eleanor Wikstrom, SF Mayor London Breed, Scott McKibben, CA Assemblymember Buffy Wicks, Schools Superintendent Tony Thurmond, Berkeley Councilmember Ben Bartlett @BenBartlett, Raiders Charles Woodson, 49ers Jerry Rice, Grand Lake Theater Owner Allan Michaan, Gary Meyer Telluride, Eat Drink Films, C.J. Hirschfeld, Issac Kos-Reed, Salsa-By-The-Lake, AMC Cinemark TinselTown, Children’s Fairyland, Irvine City Manager John Russo, Guy Fieri, CAO Edward Reiskin, Raiders Coach Jon Gruden Running Back Josh Jacobs, Stanford HC David Shaw, Tri Ngo, Atlanta Falcons Coach Dan Quinn, Michael Mina, NFL Draft Mr. Irrelevant Head Melanie Fitch, Paul Satala. Eva Crawford, Lauren Weisheit, Subscribe to ’s @ Channel, today!

About the Author

Zennie Abraham
Zennie Abraham is the CEO of Zennie62Media

Ben Bartlett Berkeley Councilmember Introduces “Safety For All: George Floyd Community Safety Act

Councilmember Ben Bartlett, Coalition App For City Of Berkeley Virtual Town Hall April 22nd, 2020

Oakland News Now Recent Blog Posts