The City of Oakland has lost yet another legal battle against the bulk terminal project it helped create, and against Phil Tagami, the man it once tried to get out of the project via The Tioga Report in 2011. Overall, The City of Oakland has racked up approximately $10 million in legal fees to date.
And in a post-George Floyd Murder world, Oakland could have given that $10 million to African-American community development organizations rather than getting its butt kicked in court again and again. Now, some are openly mentioning wanting to go down the same path, yet again, and have the City of Oakland try what supposedly would be another coal ban.
The people who want this don’t work within the City of Oakland, so one can’t blame it for the dumb idea, but the City’s not shooting it down, either.
That makes this vlogger wonder: are the City of Oakland, the Sierra Club, and the “No Coal In Oakland, But Truck Smoke In West Oakland Is Ok” group really just so collectively ego driven that they can’t see a way toward a compromise? The parties claim that the concerns are environmental, but a simple read of the history of the project brings that into question.
First, the City of Oakland-commissioned Tioga Report in 2011 pointed out that coal was the commodity that provided the best chance for the Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal to generate a profit. Contrary to the crazy assertions that have come out of some noise-makers, Phil Tagami did not identify coal for the Oakland Bulk and Oversized Terminal, or “OBOT”, Oakland did.
It was Phil Tagami who insisted on building an innovative and environmentally-safe OBOT facility, even to the point of firing Kinder-Morgan, and finding Insight Terminal Solutions. Why? Because Kinder-Morgan didn’t want to use covered hopper cars to haul coal, and Mr. Tagami did. So, off went the collective heads of Kinder-Morgan in 2014.
In short, between knocking off Kinder-Morgan, developing a hauling process so clean it’s considered over-kill by coal industry experts, and launching the one of the lowest emission engines available in the world to haul the rail cars, and called The Oakland Global Rail Enterprise, or OGRE, Phil Tagami has done what the very Tioga Report bet he could not do: prove he had the credibility, certainty, and capacity to build OBOT such that it would be, as now former Oakland Economic Development head Fred Blackwell said “a real gift to the environmental community.”
So, why is Oakland seemingly intent on standing in Phil’s way? What is it about Phil Tagami, or anyone who’s local and in business, that seems to cause the City of Oakland to want to find reasons to work against that person? In Phil’s case, he tried for 10 years to get The Rotunda Project, and when he finally won the right to develop it in 1998, did such a kick-ass job (no surprise here) that those who doubted him were left with their jaws dragging the floor.
Then, many of those same people doubted Phil Tagami could redevelop the 30-years-decrepit Fox Theater. And now, many of those same people have bought tickets to see concerts with legends like David Byrne in that same place.
And now, in the middle of worldwide pandemic, and with world-wide demand for coal forecast to go on the upswing, and with six American states hungry to get coal to overseas markets that want it, and with many needing basic jobs in those states and in Oakland and the SF Bay Area, and with OBOT having the appropriate environmental controls and also funding, and Oakland having got its tail kicked in court, again, one would reasonably think it’s time for the City of Oakland to give up and work with Phil and Insight Terminal Solutions.
The reason why I sought Insight Terminal Solutions as a Zennie62Media content client was that I’ve lived with the OBOT project going back to 1988, when the Port of Oakland first (at least for me) started talking about the need for a bulk marine terminal. And then, in 1991, a deepwater bulk terminal was selected as an economic priority for Oakland. Moreover, the 1996 Seaport Plan For the San Francisco Bay Area called for seven new bulk terminal berths by 2020. And over the years, I’ve seen Oakland first seemingly primed to focus on the objective of building OBOT, only to suddenly and seemingly inexplicably change its mind.
Add in Oakland City Attorney Barbara Parker’s statement that the City of Oakland wasn’t aware of coal in the project until 2015, when they were the ones who found it via the Tioga Study in 2011, and that was the last straw for me. The mainstream media was acting like it was bought and paid for by the environmental lobby; some organization charged with getting out the real truth was needed. Enter Zennie62Media, Inc and Oakland News Now.
In closing, the City of Oakland should stop this awful pattern of anti-economic development practices. From not using tax increment financing to save the Kaiser Headquarters Project, to the current failure to call on the Federal Government to get emergency disaster money to it in the wake of the most destructive protests in the city’s history, to the continued spending on the legal fees for fighting Phil Tagami as if it was a drunken sailor, to the loss of the Oakland Raiders and the Golden State Warriors, the City sends the basic message that it does not really know how to create jobs.
And it sends that message at a time when Oaklanders are counting on the City of Oakland to really know what it’s doing. Our very quality of life is taking a giant nose-dive because Oakland’s government is afraid to act, and only knows how to levy taxes, file lawsuits, and stop development. That’s not a formula for economic development success.
You may also like
Oakland News Now Recent Posts
- 🏈🏀🏒 BEST BETS for MONDAY: Saints-Seahawks Picks, NBA Predictions & NHL Best Bets October 25, 2021
- ‘Absolutely, this is a coup’: Adviser to Sudan’s PM speaks to CNN October 25, 2021
- $1000 for Tom Brady’s Game Ball? | Good Morning Football October 25, 2021
- FREE NFL 10/25/21 Picks and Predictions Today NFL Betting Tips and Analysis October 25, 2021
- Amazon is a microcosm of the U.S. economy, says Fast Money editor October 25, 2021
- Chicago Bears Live – Matt Nagy Media Availability October 25, 2021
- NBA Betting Today – Monday 10/25 – Picks + Props + Sports Betting Analysis October 25, 2021
- Julianna Margulies on playing an LGBTQ+ character on “The Morning Show” October 25, 2021
- Storm dumps fresh snow across the sierra October 25, 2021
- Jumpsuit Plus Sizes / Women’s Clothing Boutique Fashion Trends 💕 October 25, 2021
- Turk: If I Was Still an Addict, I Would Look for the Drugs that Killed Michael K Williams (Part 15) October 25, 2021
- Citigroup CEO: ‘Very tangible benefits’ come from digital currencies October 25, 2021
- Finn Bálor’s Demon summons him: WWE Canvas 2 Canvas October 25, 2021
- Awarding the Best Performances of Week 7 | Good Morning Football October 25, 2021
- New Jersey Governor: We Can’t Afford To Go Backwards October 25, 2021
- Sexy Stylish Skirts / Women’s Clothing Boutique Fashion Trends 🌸 October 25, 2021
- #Shorts Rachel Scott of ABC News gives us a news brief on Texas Abortion Law Consequences October 25, 2021
- Verizon Game Rewind | Warriors Complete California Sweep in Sacramento – Oct. 24, 2021 October 25, 2021
- BREAKING: Petrol price hits a record 142.94p per litre October 25, 2021
- Understanding Facebook’s issues ahead of the company’s Q3 earnings report October 25, 2021
- Rex Ryan does NOT believe in the Green Bay Packers’ defense | Get Up October 25, 2021
- ‘Squid Game’ sparks global Korean Dalgona candy craze October 25, 2021
- Top African goalscorers | Premier League | Riyad Mahrez, Mohamed Salah, Didier Drogba & more October 25, 2021
- Braves headed to the World Series for the first time since 1999 October 25, 2021
- Citigroup CEO Jane Fraser joins Yahoo Finance’s All Markets Summit 2021 October 25, 2021
- ‘Day of reckoning’ for tech industry, Lo Toney says October 25, 2021
- WorldView: Sudan’s acting prime minister detained in apparent military coup October 25, 2021
- Jason Sudeikis Reprises His Joe Biden Impression On ‘Saturday Night Live’ October 25, 2021
- World Series Preview: Astros, Braves show down in 2021 Fall Classic! October 25, 2021
- Tamron Hall talks new book, ‘As the Wicked Watch’ October 25, 2021
- Andrew Ross Sorkin: Facebook Controversies Won’t Impact Company’s Bottom Line October 25, 2021
- Republicans block voting rights bill as filibuster threatens Biden’s agenda October 25, 2021
- Citigroup CEO on inflation: ‘We’re probably in for a bit of a brutal winter’ October 25, 2021
- Nikki A.S.H Learns Things About India: WWE Superstars Ki Paathshala – Ep.3: WWE Now India October 25, 2021
- Alissa Violet SUING FaZe Clan for Shares of $300 Million Org October 25, 2021
- Robert Costa: Trump Was Calling Into Willard ‘War Room’ October 25, 2021
- Setting Up A Make-Or-Break Week For Infrastructure: Where Are We? October 25, 2021
- NBA Picks 10/25/2021 | Free NBA Bets, Picks, and Predictions October 25, 2021
- Boris Johnson ‘Touch and Go’ If COP26 Climate Summit Will Be a Success October 25, 2021
- Protests Erupt in Sudan As Prime Minister Arrested in Military Takeover October 25, 2021